While The Dream of Gerontius may be the unlikely focus of Alan Bennett's play The Choral, the work hardly needs a popularity boost. Edward Gardner's vibrant latest recording is among several released in the past 24 months, with an additional one due early next year.
Captured live at the BBC Proms in 2022, the energetic reading boasts a lot in its favor. Clayton captures the feverish nature of the protagonist near death whose every sensation is simultaneously a fear and a intrigue. His valiant voice thrills in the magnificent hymn, Holy and Strong, while an expressive use of text highlights the thought-provoking dialogue session in the second part. Barton's rich voice has a palpable immediacy as well as providing plentiful resources of comfort. Platt's craggy bass voice is ideally matched to the angel character.
Edward Gardner is highly theatrical, conveying the narrative with an nearly operatic boldness. The LPO performs as if a group of demons was at its back, paralleled by the combined forces of the London Philharmonic and Hallé choruses. Here and there, the acoustic deprives the recording of the final bit of directness, but all in all it's a excellent accomplishment to rank alongside Nicholas Collon's arresting Finnish version released in recent months.